Holy Trinity Lutheran Church, Middle Island, NY

You Belong Here

At Holy Trinity Lutheran Church, you’ll find a welcoming community rooted in Christ’s love and grace. Whether you’ve been part of a church all your life or are just beginning to explore faith, there’s a place for you here to worship, grow, and belong.

Plan Your Visit

east

The interior of the sanctuary of Holy Trinity Lutheran Church in Middle Island, NY.

Pastor preaching at Holy Trinity Lutheran Church in Middle Island, NY.

The Middle Island Church You Have Been Looking For

At Holy Trinity Lutheran Church, you’ll find a warm, Christ-centered community that feels genuine and welcoming. We’re friendly and down-to-earth, with a worship style that’s comfortable and rooted in God’s Word. Here, faith is personal, relationships are real, and everyone is treated with care and respect. Whether you’re new to church or looking for a place to grow, you’ll find people ready to welcome you and walk with you in Christ’s love.

Come and See

Visitor Information

We invite you to worship with us.

Location
93 Yaphank Middle Island Road
Middle Island, NY 11953-2370

Worship Times
Sunday Traditional - 9:00am
Sunday Acoustic - 11:00am
Wednesday Contemporary - 7:00pm

Sunday School
9:00am & 11:00am

Bible Studies
Thursday - 10:00am and 7:00pm
Saturday - 8:00am

Plan Your Visit

What People Are Saying

"Absolutely love this cozy church sitting in the woods with so much spiritual faith projected to all members and visitors. Thank you so much to all of you who serve in making our lives peaceful thru these times of instability in our world. In true appreciation from the bottom of my heart and in Jesus name, AMEN"

Natasha Kesoglou

"The word of God is clearly taught and shared with a warm and loving congregation."

Walter Baepler

"Great place to get to know people in the area. Kids love the vacation Bible school and Sunday service."

Kelly Stadier

"I love the outdoor service which will be back in the spring. I love every message from Pastor Dave. He is so Blessed with his ability to teach from his heart. Every time I go I get spiritually fed and I always leave feeling better than before I came."

John Merkent

Our Pastor

Meet Our Pastor

Ministries

Grief Share

S.O.U.L. Supporting Others United in Loss – A Christ centered program through Grief Share for people who have lost loved ones. The 13-week program uses videos and discussions to cover topics such as loneliness, anger, regrets, fear, sadness, hope, resilience and much more, helping individuals in their grief journey.

Community Food Pantry

Our food pantry serves a 53 sq mile area within the Longwood School District, caring for approximately 150 families on a weekly basis. Clients are welcomed with the love of Christ, coffee, cake, and conversation before and after they select their own items in a true shopping experience.

Annual Coat Drive

Providing new and gently used coats, hats, gloves and scarves for people in need begins in the late summer. Individual donors and two other local churches have contributed, increasing the number and variety of cold weather items gathered.

A Lutheran Church in Middle Island, New York

What Is a Lutheran Church?

Holy Trinity is a Lutheran Church. This means that we are a Christian church that:

Bases its teachings on the Bible
Emphasizes salvation by grace through faith through faith in Jesus Christ and His death on the cross.
Embraces God's Word, the sacraments, and prayer as the center of Christian worship.
Engages in acts of Christian witness and love locally, domestically, and abroad.

A Member of the Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod

The Lutheran Church-Missouri Synod (LCMS) is a denomination that confesses the historic, orthodox Christian faith, a faith built on "the foundation of the apostles and prophets, Christ Jesus himself being the cornerstone" (Eph. 2:20).

The LCMS, headquartered in St. Louis, Mo., is mission-oriented and Bible-based. LCMS doctrine reflects the teachings of Dr. Martin Luther, as summarized in The Book of Concord: The Confessions of the Evangelical Lutheran Church.

Churches in Middle Island, NY

Churches in Middle Island play a vital role in building community, offering hope, and sharing God's love. Holy Trinity stands as a prime example—welcoming neighbors, serving those in need, and above all, extending the grace of God in Jesus Christ to all.